Restaurants in Shelter Island Heights, NY

18 Bay Restaurant

$$$$

Italian, Bars, Soul Food

Caci Shelter Island

$$

Italian

Chez Marie

$$

Food

House On Chase Creek

$$

Food

Isola

$$

Italian

Leon 1909

$$

Italian, French

Léon 1909

$$

Food

Osprey Bar & Lounge

$$

New American

Ram's Head Inn

$$

Food

Red Maple

$$

New American, Seafood, Sandwiches

Shelter Island House

$$

Bars, Bed & Breakfast

Stars Cafe

$$

Cafes

The Flying Goat

$$

Seafood

The Nancy

$$

Food

West Neck Guesthouse

$$

Bed & Breakfast